From Under the Ground: Why Remembering the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising is Important

By Jason Platzner
It only took one week after the Germans entered the Polish city of Warsaw to establish the foundations of the Warsaw ghetto. By the beginning of October 1939, Jews were forced to public embarrassment by wearing their Star of David at all times, their schools, property, and jobs were for the most part forfeited to their invaders. Nearly a year later, they were forced into the sealed ghetto, surrounded by walls with barbed wire with deplorable conditions that worsened with their captors’ cruelty. Families starved and died in the streets and the poor medical treatment couldn’t halt the widespread amounts of disease throughout the enclosed space, and yet, this was only the beginning of the Jews suffering.

In the summer of 1942, the ghettos were liquidated. Nearly 83,000 Jews already died from various causes in the preface to the mass deportation. Approximately 300,000 Jews were sent to Treblinka, widely known as an extermination camp, where 35,000 of them met their deaths. The Germans planned another deportation of those who remained in the ghetto. That is when a group of mostly young men and women got ready for a fight. The Jewish Fighting Organization led by a 23-year-old man called on all Jews to resist the march onto the horrifying railroad cars. A few months later in January 1943, the Nazis began another round-up of Jews. To their shock and horror, the Jews they rounded up produced weapons and began firing on them. The intense firefight dismayed the German soldiers and they realized quickly that they weren’t prepared or properly taught how to fight a guerilla war in the urban decay of Warsaw. The Germans retreated and the Jewish underground celebrated, but moreover, they prepared for their next clash.

On April 19, 1943, after Himmler promised to give Hitler a Jew-free Warsaw for his birthday, the uprising commenced on the Eve of Passover. Less than a thousand Jewish fighters, severely under-armed and prepared faced a force of nearly 2,000 well trained and equipped German Stormtroopers supported by tanks and heavy weapons. Despite the incredible odds, the Jews held out for several days and repelled many German attacks. The fighting would continue for nearly a month until the commander of the Jewish forces was presumably killed along with most of his staff. Still, the surviving fighters rose again and again, and in August of 1944 took part in another uprising to quell Nazi suppression. Having had enough of the myriad of uprisings, the Germans destroyed almost all of the once beautiful city.

The uprisings showed the world that the Jews were no longer marching into certain death willingly, but more importantly, the uprisings showed that to the Jews themselves. Many young Jews were aware of their inevitable deaths and decided to take a stand regardless of the outcome. The mass amount of photographic evidence of the holocaust shows families, young, old, and sick being led into rail cars or rounded up by soldiers heading to their ends in terror. The uprising showed the world that this wasn’t the case, there were many who fought and died fighting rather than give up their freedom. It taught the Jews of the world not to ever lay down and accept hatred again, something that is still relevant today.

 

 

 

Why War Movies Mean More Than Just Thrills

 

This past year has seen the release of quite a few war films, namely several movies based during World War II. Robert Zemeckis’s Allied, Mel Gibson’s Hacksaw Ridge, and Christopher Nolan’s Dunkirk are among the most recent big blockbuster productions which all hit the silver screen to critical acclaim. Dark Knight and Inception director Nolan, received recent praise for its dramatic and realistic portrayal of the retreat from French beaches after the British Expeditionary Force were beaten back by Adolf Hitler’s army. He also obtained universal acclaim due to his stylistic non-linear structure of the story and dramatic, somewhat terrifying, battle scenes although it only received a PG-13 rating. Mel Gibson’s Hacksaw Ridge also met with critical acclaim for the presentation of a Medal of Honor winning conscientious objector Desmond Doss, famous for his acts as a medic during his war service. Finally, the fictitious Allied brought Brad Pitt out as a Royal Canadian Airforce intelligence officer amidst Axis-occupied Morocco, partnered with a female French Resistance fighter played by Marion Cotillard.

Instead of focusing on the films, their actors, and the directors in their respected places you could think of the real events. The events portrayed in Dunkirk occurred in the spring and early summer of 1940 in France. For a soldier to be in the British Army at that point in time he had to be at least 18-years-old and born in the year 1922 or earlier. Today that boy would be 95-years-old. I’m sure there are plenty of 95-year-old (and older) men (and women) still walking around, but there aren’t many. There certainly aren’t many World War II vets on the streets anymore. According to the US Department of Veterans Affairs, we are losing approximately 372 veterans per day and only 620,000 of the 16 million Americans who served in World War II were alive in 2017. Sure 620,000 is a whole lot, but the VA also estimates by 2025 about 57,000 will be left and if that continues on the same slope, the last WWII vet could die as early as 2038. If you can grasp the terror of this, then you are one of the very little amount of people who have given it a thought that we will be alive to see the Greatest Generation die out.

As a history buff, to hear that any veteran of any war die is emotional for me, with a grandfather that has recently passed fight in the miserable Pacific during World War II, seeing these numbers on the page hit home. That’s why when I see these movies, I tend not to see them as Saving Private Ryan wannabe’s, but instead updated versions on what we can show newer generations about history. The more we keep the stories alive, the more history will not be forgotten. If you asked a regular teenager on the street about World War II, chances are he will know facts only in movies, TV, and videogames. If that is how history will be presented, then we need to keep churning these out to give more views on our history. Though we are inching towards the centennial of the final year of World War One, the last veterans of that war died about 7-years ago. The fact that we have history walking on our streets unnoticed at almost all times becomes a troubling thought for me personally. Kids who grow up and never very much care, let alone ask about what their grandparents did during the war is a slap in the face to those who aim to preserve their historical accomplishments.

With the film Dunkirk now awaiting home-media release, the next WWII blockbuster is up-for-grabs. A thousand stories erupt out of wartime, so fresh source material is abundant. With the dwindling amount of veterans and their depletion a looming reality, the time to bring their stories to the screen seem more important now than ever. That being said, every war should have updated films and media to further give our new and future generations a creative take on our veterans’ histories.

Up ↑